ADD Medications

Which ADHD Medication Is Best? ADD Stimulants, Nonstimulants & More

Vyvanse. Ritalin. Concerta. Adderall. Strattera. And myriad others. The market for ADHD medications is so bloated that finding the right treatment feels impossible and overwhelming at times. Here, an ADHD specialist explains the options in terms we can all understand.

pharmacy shelves full of ADHD medications - should you switch to a different medication?
illustration of pharmacy shelves full of ADHD medication options

What Is the Best ADHD Medication?

I saw a child who, after receiving extensive evaluation, was diagnosed with inattentive attention deficit disorder (ADHD or ADD). When I talked with his mother about starting him on the ADHD stimulant medication methylphenidate, she asked, “Why not Vyvanse? That’s the one that Ty Pennington takes, right? It works great for him!” I explained my reasons for prescribing methylphenidate, not Vyvanse, and realized that the flurry of ads for ADHD medications had confused her.

Which ADHD medication is best? Dexedrine or Adderall? Concerta or Strattera? What about Wellbutrin? Guanfacine? Others like Vyvanse or Ritalin?

Many parents and adults are similarly confused by the treatment choices for ADHD. The Food and Drug Administration requires that a medication be given a different name according to its form (capsule, tablet, liquid, patch) or release mechanism (released immediately or over an extended period of time). Here’s an example: Ritalin is a tablet that is released immediately into the bloodstream and works for four hours. Ritalin LA, on the other hand, is a capsule that releases over a longer period of time and works for eight hours. Different names, even though both contain the same medicine — methylphenidate.

Before we go any further, I want to give you a quick refresher on why doctors prescribe stimulants for the condition.

How Do Stimulant Medications Treat ADHD?

ADHD is a neurologically based disorder, resulting from the deficiency of a neurotransmitter, or a group of neurotransmitters, in specific areas of the brain. Neurotransmitters are chemicals that transmit signals between nerve cells by bridging the synapse (or gap) between them.

The key neurotransmitter involved is norepinephrine, along with its building blocks, dopa and dopamine. The primary medications used to treat ADHD stimulate specific cells within the brain to produce more of the deficient neurotransmitter. That’s why these medications are called stimulants.

[Free Download: The Ultimate Guide to ADHD Medication]

The two main classes of stimulant medications, methylphenidate and dextro-amphetamine — both are generic names — have been used since the 1960s. All brand-name stimulants are variations of these two medications. Adderall is a modification of dextro-amphetamine, for instance, while methylphenidate comes as an immediate-release tablet, a chewable tablet, a liquid, a skin patch, an intermediate-acting (extended-release) tablet, a long-acting (extended-release) capsule, and a long-acting (extended-release) tablet. Each variation has its own name, but the medicine that treats symptoms is the same — methylphenidate.

How is ADHD Medication Dosed?

Parents of children with ADHD ask me: “My child was on Adderall 10 mg, and my doctor changed her prescription to Vyvanse 60 mg. Why was the dose increased?” The reasons for the numbers have to do with target dose and release mechanism.

Target dose: Each product releases a specific amount of medication into the blood over a given period of time. The FDA requires that the number value for each product represent the total amount of the medication in the tablet/liquid/capsule/patch, not the amount in the blood at any one time. Thus, if the medication, let’s say methylphenidate, is in the form of a four-hour tablet, and it releases 5 mg over that time, it is called methylphenidate 5 mg. A capsule of Adderall that releases 10 mg immediately and 10 mg four hours later is called Adderall XR 20. The number is not based on the amount released at any one time, but on the total amount of the medication in the capsule.

Release mechanism: This indicates the length of time a medication will remain available and active. Stimulants come in a variety of forms — tablet, capsule, liquid, skin patch — and release medication in an hour, four hours, or over eight or 12 hours.

How Does Concerta Work? How Is It Different From Other ADHD Medications?

Many people are confused about the ADHD medication Concerta. Designed to last 12 hours, Concerta has a “sponge” on the bottom of the capsule, medication on top, and a tiny hole above the medication. As the capsule passes through the gastrointestinal tract and absorbs moisture, the sponge expands and pushes the medication out of the hole.

[Read: Your Toughest ADHD Medication Questions, Answered!]

The number value assigned to each dose is confusing. Take Concerta 18 mg. If the goal is to release 5 mg consistently every four hours over a 12-hour period, then there needs to be 15 mg in the capsule. However, it takes time for the sponge to become moist enough to start to expand. So an initial release of medication is needed until the sponge starts working. Researchers figured out that it should be 3 mg. Thus, to release 5 mg over 12 hours, one needs the initial 3 mg, plus 5 mg every four hours during the 12 hours. The total amount of medication is 18 mg. That’s why the medication is called Concerta 18.

Same ADHD Medication, Different Formulations

Medications such as methylphenidate and dextro-amphetamine also come in liquid forms. The patient information sheet inside the medication’s box or packaging states how much medication is in each unit of liquid; for example, 5 mg per 5 ml of liquid. Another methylphenidate product — Daytrana* — is a patch that releases medication through the skin and into the bloodstream. It should start to work in about one hour, and remain effective until about one hour after being removed (usually around nine hours). Daytrana 30 mg contains about 30 mg of methylphenidate, and releases about 3.3 mg of it per hour.

As if that weren’t challenging enough, amphetamine and methylphenidate are made of two isomers, called dextro and levo isomers. When the first amphetamine products used for ADHD were studied, experts learned that the dextro form was more effective in managing symptoms than the levo form. Thus, dextro-amphetamine became the primary product used to treat the condition. (Adderall, prescribed to many patients who have been diagnosed with ADHD, is a mixture of dextro- and levo-amphetamine, plus other amphetamine salts.) A similar finding was recently made on methylphenidate. Researchers learned that the dextro form was more effective than the levo form. Dextro-methylphenidate is manufactured under the name of Focalin.

*FDA is warning that permanent loss of skin color may occur with use of the Daytrana patch (methylphenidate transdermal system) for Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). FDA added a warning to the drug label to describe this skin condition, which is known as chemical leukoderma. See the FDA Drug Safety Communication for more information.

Which ADHD Medication is Best?

In short, there’s no way to know which stimulant medication will work “best” for any one person’s ADHD. It’s often related to your history, your genetics, and your or your child’s unique metabolism. The next time a doctor rattles off medications and dosages that might be appropriate for you or your child, consult this comprehensive list to give yourself a much better idea of what he’s talking about and how to decide which might be the best choice.

Methylphenidate

  • Generic: tablet; immediate release; lasts about four hours; comes in 5, 10, 15 mg dosages
  • Aptensio XR: brand name; capsule; immediate and extended release; lasts 12 hours; comes in 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 40, 50, and 60mg dosages
  • Concerta: brand name; tablet; lasts about 12 hours; comes in 18, 27, 36, 54 mg dosages
  • Daytrana: brand name; skin patch; lasts about eight hours; comes in 10, 15, 20, 30 mg dosages
  • Ritalin: brand name; tablet; immediate release; lasts about four hours; comes in 5, 10, 15 mg dosages
  • Ritalin LA: brand name; capsule; lasts about eight hours; comes in 10, 20, 30, 40 mg dosages
  • Ritalin SR: brand name; tablet; lasts about eight hours; comes in 20 mg dosage
  • Metadate CD: brand name; capsule; lasts eight hours; comes in 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60 mg dosages
  • Metadate ER: brand name; tablet; lasts eight hours; comes in 10, 20 mg dosages
  • Methylin: brand name; liquid and chewable tablets; immediate release; lasts four hours; tablets come in 2.5, 5, 10 mg dosages, liquid in 5 mg/tsp and 10mg/tsp dosages
  • QuilliChew ER: brand name; chewable tablet; extended release; lasts eight hours; comes in 20, 30, and 40 mg dosages
  • Quillivant XR: brand name; liquid; extended release; lasts 12 hours; dosages range from 20 to 60 mg

More ADHD Stimulant Medications

In addition to methylphenidates, there are several other families of stimulant medications that treat ADHD.

Dextro-Methylphenidate

  • Focalin: brand name; tablet; lasts four hours; immediate release; comes in 2.5, 5, 10 mg dosages
  • Focalin XR: brand name; capsule; lasts eight hours; immediate release followed by second delayed release; comes in 5, 10, 15, 20, 30, 40 mg dosages

Dextro-Amphetamine

  • Generic; tablet; immediate release; lasts four hours; comes in 5, 10 mg dosages
  • Dexedrine Spansule: brand name; capsule; immediate release followed by gradual release; lasts eight hours; comes in 5, 10, 15 mg dosages
  • ProCentra: brand name; liquid; immediate release; lasts four hours; comes in 5 mg/tsp dosage

Modified Amphetamine Mixture

  • Adderall: brand name; tablet; immediate release; lasts four hours; comes in 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, 15, 20, 30 mg dosages
  • Adderall XR: brand name; capsule; immediate and delayed release; lasts eight hours; comes in 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30 mg dosages
  • Adzenys XR-ODT: brand name; orally-disintegrating tablet; immediate and delayed release; lasts up to 12 hours; comes in 3.1 mg, 6.3 mg, 9.4 mg, 12.5 mg, 15.7 mg, and 18.8 mg dosages
  • Dyanavel XR: brand name; liquid; extended release; lasts 13 hours; dosages range from 2.5 mg to 10 mg per day
  • Evekeo: brand name; tablet; immediate release; lasts four fours; comes in 5 and 10 mg dosages
  • Vyvanse: brand name; capsule and chewable tablet; lasts 10 to 12 hours; comes in 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70 mg dosages

3 Related Links

  1. Are there any studies that look at the long-term health effects of taking either methylphenidate or dextro-amphetamine for an extended period? Changes in aging stress hormones or metabolism?

  2. >>> I hope parents of children on ADHD stimulants read this, especially if they are punishing their child for stimulant-rebound meltdowns. <<<

    Vyvanse is “slow-on, slow-off,” with about a 2-hour ramp-up/ramp-down time. That means that you don’t get nearly the medication rebound that happens with other stimulants. Having experienced the rebound of short-acting stimulants myself, I am amazed that doctors still prescribe them. (It may be due to expense/insurance, but that needs to change.) Talk about “do no harm.” It is a horrible experience; you feel like dirt. (See below for a detailed description of my experience.) And it is happening to young kids who can’t describe their experience.

    I feel so sad for all the young kiddoes suffering daily rebounds, often at homework time, and the parents who are trying to manage the meltdowns.

    Vyvanse is the only medication that has been effective for my two daughters w/o significant side effects. I started taking it 3 years ago, and now both of my daughters as well as my sister do. She thanked me profusely for telling her about it – she had been taking Ritalin and didn’t like it so she had given up. She did have to go through a big rigmarole with her insurance, but they did approve it.

    I wish it had existed in 2014 when my younger daughter was diagnosed with ADHD at the end of 1st grade. Due to ineffectiveness and/or intolerable side effects of the medications we tried (several stimulants of each type, as well as each of the non-stimulant ADHD medications), we gave up on medication and she has gone untreated for nearly 4 years, poor thing (until just recently, when we tried Daytrana — ineffective, and now Vyvanse). However, she managed well (good grades, good behavior — but would fall apart after school) until this year – 5th grade was just more than she could handle untreated, and she was diagnosed with anxiety and depression.

    When we learned last year that my middle school daughter had stealth ADHD, I couldn’t believe that our then-psychiatrist gave her Ritalin with the instruction to go to the nurse’s office during her (very short) lunch. Needless to say, she didn’t go, and he wouldn’t prescribe Vyvanse. I figured it wasn’t used in kids.

    When we recently switched to a pediatric psychiatrist with a top-notch reputation, she prescribed Vyvanse for both girls without blinking an eye.

    I would say that Vyvanse has changed our lives. (I have no affiliation with any pharmaceutical company or anything else remotely related.)

    I hope my recounting of our experience helps someone else. Our lives would have been so much better had Vyvanse been available in 2012.

    ———

    Here’s an email I wrote to a parenting coach / child therapist who specializes in challenging children:

    “I now know how HORRIBLE [my daughter] felt during 1st grade, and thousands of other kids feel when they take short-, mid-acting stimulants and they wear off (right at homework time). It’s really rough and unlike any physical illness you might be familiar with. I felt sick, but not like a flu. Metaphorically, kind of like bad nausea if applied to the whole body and brain/mind. A state that a child’s brain really shouldn’t have to be in (but of course I recognize the need and advantage of stimulants) and that a child shouldn’t have to experience.

    “I wish I had a way to tell all the parents, so they could really sympathize with their children. I know that we found the horrible rebound behavior [my daughter] had, to be stressful for US, but didn’t REALLY get how horrible she must have felt.

    And her response:

    “Thanks for the info on the rebound.  I have witnessed and heard countless stories of the crash that occurs when kids’ meds wear off but didn’t know the chemical reason and so it is helpful to hear from an articulate adult on it so that I can share it with parens whose kids cannot explain it.”

Leave a Reply