|
Agreed
I wrote a very verbose response in another thread a few months ago, but to distill the message.
1 - Not all stimulants work the same way in the brain chemically, caffeine and the prescription meds for ADHD are chemically different.
2 - Studies show that caffeine improve the focus of non-ADHD, so that alone is inconclusive to anything. In fact, many doctor's and diet recommendations for ADHD advise against caffeine as being counter-productive, but I have not read the direct research myself - so I do not have a personal opinion. When I discussed the topic with a psychiatrist that I knew, based on a poster that said, "my psychiatrist said." I started wtih "Some psychiatrists say that..." He laughed heartily.
3. Some folks market caffeine as the next best thing. If it sounds to good, it probably is.
4 - If there is a benefit, it is heart to find a standardized, time-release dosage that will not create a roller-coaster.
In general, I have found that each individual responds to drugs (prescription, OTC, or otherwise) differently, but from personal experience, as a practitioner, and as a critical consumer of scientific research I am extremely skeptical.
http://askdreric-schoolpsychologist.blogspot.com/
Quote
|