Page 1 of 1 1

active forum Post Reply

Thread : Ph.D. teacher needs ideas for new directions  
10 Nov 2008 @ 12:54 PM
TexasWoman Join Date: Mon 10th Nov 2008
Threads: Posts:
Ph.D. teacher needs ideas for new directions

So, it took 10 years, but I got my Ph.D. (Whether or not I should have is a question it's way too late to ask. :)

My field is Curriculum and Instruction with a focus on foreign language instruction, particularly Spanish. However, I'm stuck right now teaching high school, which is (a) a BAD fit for me in terms of the workload and in terms of having to spend time on stuff like "tuck in your shirt," "put on your ID badge," "you've shown up without pencil or paper again?" and (b) it's exactly what I was doing before grad school, albeit with better pay. I'm teaching English and had hoped at least to switch back over to Spanish this year to see if that made it better; I like the kids, we just bought our first house and it's 5 minutes from work, and did I mention the pay is good? I have to stick to jobs that have benefits because my husband's unlikely ever to get them through his own work, so I can't afford to do a part-time version of my dream job, community college Spanish, because part-timers don't get insurance.

The few full-time community-college teaching jobs are incredibly competitive. I have taught part-time at the nearest CC both before I got my full-time job and while doing that job. I loved it and got great teaching reviews from my supervisor, but she was very frustrated by my difficulties staying on top of deadlines for paperwork and getting grades done and in. I feel that I might have done better at that had I had a full-time position, which would come with some dedicated office space and hours to see students; nonetheless, it's true I have trouble with some of those same aspects of my HS teaching job. I have a feeling that her frustration with the deadlines (she, too, was working a full-time job elsewhere, and doing far more paperwork than I had to, so it's not as if I could say a lot about "Well, if it weren't for my other full-time job"). I have the feeling my reference from her has slipped -- not necessarily to anything bad, just no longer the rave review that I need for such competitive positions. A mentor has suggested I contact my supervisor to ask about this, and even offered to go over any notes I might write out as preparation; even so, the thought is highly intimidating and I haven't yet forced myself to write out what I'd say. For those who are wondering, yes, I will try as soon as I hit "post this new thread."

Teaching at a four-year college is almost unthinkable, not because I couldn't like it, but because my grad school didn't know what to do with someone who didn't have a master's going into the Ph.D., so what I did during my coursework didn't prepare me to try for faculty jobs. I didn't even know I was supposed to be doing some of the things it turns out "everyone" knows Ph.D. students are supposed to do so that they will be ready to teach college by the end... see, another thing I didn't know that "everyone" knows is that a Ph.D. in education is basically for people who want to teach and/or research at the university. So those jobs expect publications, evidence of scholarly output or at least potential, and so on. Not only would I need them in order to land the job, but I'd likely need them in order to keep the job. Add to that the fact that, as I mentioned before, we just bought a house at last, so after years of being in a position to move anywhere in the region that I might find work, I'm now tied to my current city. On the bright side, it's quite large.

I'm not 100% attached to staying in a teaching position. If I could find either an education-related position in something like student services OR helping educators OR curriculum development OR education policy OR work with some kind of non-profit organization, those all appeal as well. Unfortunately, for reasons I've already stated, it would be hard to be able to afford to go to the entry-level jobs there, though I wouldn't think myself above the work, and when I've tried for jobs that don't require an advanced degree, the degree to which I'm overqualified works against me in the committees' consideration.

I do own _What Color Is Your Parachute?_ and already have multiple versions of my résumé, so those bases are covered. My mentor said that there was a workshop on interviewing that she highly recommended, though I don't know when it will be offered next; need to find out, true. I'm not trying to find a perfect or stress-free job, nor to get rich. Basically, I want to provide for us, try to avoid relocation, potentially work in a job where my degree does me a little more good (though that's an expendable goal), and especially, I'd like to work in a job where I don't think every week, WHY am I in a job that involves so many things I'm not good at?!? but rather, "OK, so this is an interesting challenge..."

Thoughts?

Quote

12 Nov 2008 @ 11:24 AM Reply # 1
sam'smother Join Date: Wed 12th Nov 2008
Threads: 0 Posts: 2
Teaching

I teach at a private "career institute" type school. That might be an opiton for you and there is far less"tuck your shirt in" type duties.

Quote

20 Nov 2008 @ 6:12 PM Reply # 2
lupin Join Date: Thu 20th Nov 2008
Threads: 0 Posts: 8
You earned that PhD!!!

hey Texas Woman --

Remember this: nobody gives out PhD's by mistake. You might not have gotten great mentoring, etc, but you finished and you did it! Remember this, too: there is no higher degree granted by universities.

So the only entry level jobs you should ever be looking at are entry level jobs for new PhDs. It's true that the pay might not be as good as for a high school teacher with a PhD, but it would mean less of the shirt-tucking stuff... could be worth it.

I would say that what you want to do before you apply for anything is find some of the people who are doing work you think you would like to be doing, and ask them if they will meet with you because you are a new PhD seeking career options. Then you ask about what the job entails, what they like, what they don't like, and what kind of preparation you need to be successful in their field. Or if that sounds awful, try to go to the conferences in the field, the ones where people present research or where people in the areas you're interested in do their networking -- sometimes there is programming for grad students about how to apply for jobs etc, and often in casual conversation you can pick up hints and ideas. Even the web sites of these professional organizations can be very helpful.

And don't say you have no research experience, you wrote a dissertation of some kind, right? What are the journals in your field? You can talk to journal editors about how to turn your PhD research into a publication.

It sounds as though you have the ADD habit of self-deprecation and belittling your own accomplishments. I bet there are LOTs of people in this forum who are really really impressed that you finished a PhD... of course you're crummy at paperwork. You will need some strategies there, we all do... but you're great at other things.

Do as I say not as I do on that, I'm quite capable of thinking they gave me tenure by mistake :-)

lupin, PhD (hyperfocus won out over inattention)

Quote

Page 1 of 1 1

active forum Post Reply

« Previous Thread | Next Thread »

Local Time : 26 May 2013 3:58 AM
(Sun, 26 May 2013 07:58:28 GMT)

Copyright © 1998 - 2013 New Hope Media LLC. All rights reserved. Your use of this site is governed by our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
ADDitude does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. The material on this web site is provided for educational purposes only. See additional information.
New Hope Media, 39 W. 37th Street, 15th Floor, New York, NY 10018